---
status: resolved
claimed-by: "019fba91-eabf-76ae-b086-a37ac061d6e8"
claimed-at: "2026-07-31T20:54:32-04:00"
parent: "[[002-pi-subagents-map]]"
blocked-by:
  - "[[003-pi-subagents-herdr-compatibility-research]]"
  - "[[004-pi-subagents-pi-extension-ecosystem-research]]"
  - "[[005-pi-subagents-firstmate-and-related-tools-research]]"
  - "[[006-pi-subagents-local-config-inventory-task]]"
  - "[[011-pi-subagents-herdr-pi-integration-research]]"
  - "[[012-pi-subagents-herdr-extension-boundary-research]]"
  - "[[013-pi-subagents-pi-fork-research]]"
  - "[[014-pi-subagents-firstmate-patterns-research]]"
  - "[[019-pi-subagents-herdr-status-projection-prototype]]"
tags:
  - ticket/grill
---

# Adopt adapt or build decision

## Question

Given the researched Herdr compatibility model, Pi extension ecosystem, Firstmate-related options, and local configuration constraints, should this effort adopt an existing solution, adapt companion tooling, or build a neutral Pi extension?

## Resolution

Build a new neutral Pi extension rather than adopting Firstmate, adapting `mjakl/pi-subagent`, or extending `pi-fork` directly.
The extension should focus on Pi-native subagent behavior first and should not focus on Herdr integration in the initial decision route.
Subagent types, prompts, and policy remain Pi configuration, not extension-bundled opinion.
The extension should support both active-branch forked children for context-preserving investigation and fully independent children for adversarial review, red-green refactor checks, code review, and document sanity checks.
Subagent status should be shown inside Pi for headless/background children.
Herdr support, if added later, should be optional and adapter-shaped rather than a core dependency.
