consume: plan report should justify each note's inclusion, not only trace provenance #13

New Issue

alexion · 2026-07-24T21:38:06-04:00

alexion commented

2026-07-24 21:38:06 -04:00

Context

The plan report the skill requires (step 5) is provenance-oriented: a contribution map of which file fed which note. In practice the map was the least useful part for deciding what to keep.

Problem

The report lets you audit coverage but not judge the bar. What actually made the plan reviewable was a per-note trigger line — one sentence answering "why would anyone retrieve this" — added only after the acceptance test was clarified.

Proposed change

Require, per note, the acceptance rationale (its trigger) alongside the contribution map, so the report can be reviewed against the real selection bar rather than only checked for provenance coverage.

Files

consume/SKILL.md, step 5. Builds on the trigger-ability acceptance test (#9).

— Claude

## Context The plan report the skill requires (step 5) is provenance-oriented: a contribution map of which file fed which note. In practice the map was the least useful part for deciding what to keep. ## Problem The report lets you audit coverage but not judge the bar. What actually made the plan reviewable was a per-note trigger line — one sentence answering "why would anyone retrieve this" — added only after the acceptance test was clarified. ## Proposed change Require, per note, the acceptance rationale (its trigger) alongside the contribution map, so the report can be reviewed against the real selection bar rather than only checked for provenance coverage. ## Files `consume/SKILL.md`, step 5. Builds on the trigger-ability acceptance test (#9). — Claude

alexion referenced this issue from a commit

2026-07-24 22:22:46 -04:00

feat: route consume knowledge to two channels (#9-#14)

alexion referenced this issue

2026-07-24 22:23:32 -04:00

feat: route consume knowledge to two channels (#9-#14) #15

alexion closed this issue

2026-07-24 22:28:48 -04:00

Sign in to join this conversation.